We had another V&F game, this time Novarra, Swiss/Milan,well mainly Swiss versus France, who had Landsknechts as they didn't have the Swiss. Once more Des got AI to come up with a scenario and plan which we followed.
The Swiss pike kiels are hard as nails and once placed ,as per the scenario, French field artillery cant move , so their most potent weapon against the Swiss pikes is pretty much useless, the French cavalry took out the Milanese cavalry and the artillery ,then the Swiss pike munched through everything else, although the adventures crossbow men put up a surprisingly stiff defense, in the end the French cavalry got away but most of the infantry were destroyed, which is a historical result at least, still trying to work out what I could have done otherwise as the French player? What I am sure is that the French camp looks terrible and must be rectified! I have started on that. Another fun V and F game anyway, Ive got a backlog of AARs building up so probably more of those, Napoleonic, war of three kingdoms or Medieval!
All the best
Iain






























An interesting scenario Iain. Do you think AI was a little too conservative in its placement of the French artillery? That must have been a little annoying for you as the French player.
ReplyDeleteYes, I think some chance of at least pivoting would have given a better game, although, of course, we got an historical result!
DeleteBest Iain
Great looking game sir!
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot Michal!
DeleteBest Iain
Looks/sounds like a great game!
ReplyDeleteIts always fun pushing this collection around as theyre just so colourful!
DeleteBest Iain
Great looking game Iain. Hard to win if one side has an invincible unit, bit like a platoon of Tigers vs a platoon of Crusaders. A good game in any event and maybe a indication to check AI scenarios for this type of problem.
ReplyDeleteI agree, Ben. Battle looks fab but AI results must be given a human review before releasing the hounds of war. Iain, having played this AI-generated scenario, what would you change in a replaying of the scenario?
DeleteIn terms of playability Jonathan, Id give the French the chance/option to move/pivot the field gun, historically the French were caught with their pants down, in bed, so bleary eyed they did the best they could, so weve ended up with a good approximation in many ways!
DeleteBest Iain
Thanks Ben, yes difficult but I guess if your playing a historical battle , theres very few that are even!
DeleteBest Iain
Lovely looking game - I guess one downside of AI providing you a historical scenario is it may do as much as possible with the OOB and initial placement to ensure a historical outcome?
ReplyDeleteThanks Keith, yes, its a difficult one isnt it?
DeleteBest Iain
Lovely looking game Iain.
ReplyDeleteThanks very much Cyrus!
DeleteBest Iain
Oh my goodness me, I am just dizzy at the sight of all those troops; what an amazing spectacle. I have no experience at playing a game at this level, skirmish rules being my limit for scale and space, so this really is a feast for the eyes.
ReplyDeleteThanks Michael, yes its fun pushing large colourful units around, whatever the result!
DeleteBest Iain
Great stuff as always—really interesting seeing how the AI scenario played out.
ReplyDeleteAll the best, Andy
Thanks Andy, yes interesting AI scenario and a massive improvement on one from just a few months ago?
DeleteBest Iain
Splendid looking game, Iain.
ReplyDeleteThanks very much Richard!
DeleteBest Iain
Congratulations on the game, Iain! I’ve never come across these rules before. Why did you choose these rules specifically, rather than something more well‑known (for example, Pike&Shotte or Renaissance Warfare)?
ReplyDeleteThanks Alexie, we used to use pike and shot but with unit saving throws, most units seemed to last for ages, units in Valour and Fortitude are much more brityle, which I prefer, also starting with shooting means no mre triple moves followd by shooting which can happen in pike and shot blackpowder. V and F are Napoleonic rules available for free to download at the Perry website, thers a facebook group that has the different period variants, its a fun, brutal game!
DeleteBest Iain
Those big units make quite the spectacle! The AI presentation of the scenario is certainly good. To conclude a game, with a historical outcome and have a fun game along the way, is its own victory. Could it be justified to give the French another xBow unit?
ReplyDeleteI agree achieving a historical result is a bonus, the big problem is that the Swiss are so good and so much better than the landsknechts which Im not entirely convinced of, plus five better pike blocks to threee and rough terrain blocking the French cavalry from doing much doesnt help!
DeleteBest Iain
Wow, lovely looking game and some gorgeous models.
ReplyDeleteThanks very much Mark!
DeleteBest Iain
Beautiful looking models.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot Chris!
DeleteBest Iain
Lookedca fab game Ian. Shame to see those luvvly Milanese flags running off the table.
ReplyDeleteI dont know, I was quite pleased to see the back of them!
DeleteBest Iain
Great looking game Iain, some cracking miniatures on show there.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot Donnie!
DeleteBest Iain
Fine looking game and a historical result, but I think allowing the artillery at least a chance to pivot would have given the French a fighting chance?
ReplyDeleteYeah, I agree on all points!
DeleteBest Iain
Hmm maybe allowing the artillery to change facing a bit would have helped there? It’s easy to game if you know it can’t move.
ReplyDeleteIt wasnt so much being gamed as following the scenario?
DeleteBest Iain
Not only the pics are imposing (I repeat myself over and over, but I love how all your games look), but I'm curious about the use of AI for scenario design and how to learn to use such a tool. So interesting!
ReplyDeleteThanks Suber, I think it almost works?
DeleteBest Iain
Looked lovely as always Iain. Those Swiss pikes are tough and devastating. Need to try to find a flank, but that is easier said than done isn't it?!
ReplyDeleteBest wishes, James
Thanks James, yes tried to!
DeleteBest Iain
Fantastic looking battle Iain, so much color on the field.
ReplyDeleteIts a very colourful period Dave!
DeleteBest Iain